The publication of Alan Milburn’s Youth Guarantee Advisory Board Interim Review has reignited fundamental questions about the purpose of education in England. Its central conclusion is both provocative and deeply concerning: England’s education system is not merely struggling to prepare young people for adulthood—it is “failing by design.”
The report argues that the system has become structured around the production of qualifications rather than the development of working adults capable of participating successfully in employment and wider society.
For educators, this represents a significant challenge to decades of education policy. For Special Educational Needs and Disabilities (SEND) professionals, however, the findings may feel less like a revelation and more like confirmation of conerns that have existed for years.
The review highlights that almost one million young people aged 16–24 are currently classified as Not in Education, Employment or Training (NEET). While the causes are complex and extend beyond education alone, Milburn’s review argues that schools are playing a significant role in the problem because they remain heavily focused on examination outcomes rather than long-term life outcomes.
The report states:
“The education and skills system does not fail by accident, but by design. It is designed to produce qualifications rather than working adults.”
This statement should concern every teacher, school leader and policymaker. However, its implications are particularly significant for SEND learners, many of whom already face substantial barriers to employment, independence and social participation.
If education is genuinely intended to prepare young people for adulthood, then the question becomes unavoidable: how effectively is the current system preparing pupils with SEND for life beyond school?
The Purpose of Education: Qualifications or Preparation for Life?
Historically, education has served multiple purposes. Schools are expected to develop knowledge, promote social mobility, prepare young people for employment, foster citizenship and support personal development.
However, over the past two decades, accountability measures have increasingly focused on academic outcomes. School performance tables, Progress 8 scores, GCSE results and Ofsted inspections have created powerful incentives for schools to prioritise measurable attainment.
The Milburn Review argues that this has fundamentally distorted educational priorities. Schools are rewarded for examination performance but rarely held accountable for whether pupils secure meaningful employment, maintain independent living or participate successfully in society after leaving education.
The report notes:
“A school is recognised, regulated and rewarded for examination results, not on where the student ends up.”
For many SEND pupils, this creates a significant problem.
While academic achievement remains important, many SEND learners require schools to place equal emphasis on communication skills, emotional regulation, independence, self-advocacy, workplace readiness and social competence.
Yet these outcomes remain largely absent from accountability systems.
As a result, schools can find themselves under pressure to maximise attainment scores while dedicating less time to the broader life skills that many SEND learners need to achieve successful adult outcomes.
Why SEND Learners Are Particularly Vulnerable
The Milburn Review repeatedly highlights how the education system disadvantages those who do not fit traditional definitions of success.
The report argues that many young people are:
“effectively set up to fail.”
Importantly, it continues:
“That is not because they lack ability. It is because the system defines ability in ways that exclude them.”
This observation is particularly relevant for SEND education.
Traditional measures of attainment tend to reward:
- Strong literacy skills
- Written communication
- Examination technique
- Memory recall
- Processing speed
- Academic knowledge
These are undoubtedly valuable skills. However, they represent only a narrow subset of human ability.
Many SEND learners demonstrate significant strengths in:
- Practical problem-solving
- Visual-spatial reasoning
- Creativity
- Technical skills
- Leadership
- Empathy
- Persistence
- Innovation
Unfortunately, these strengths are often difficult to capture through traditional examination systems.
Norwich (2014) argues that inclusive education requires educational systems to adapt to learner diversity rather than expecting learners to conform to a single model of success. Yet the current accountability framework frequently does the opposite, privileging a narrow range of academic outcomes over broader indicators of capability.
Consequently, many SEND learners spend their educational careers being measured against standards that fail to recognise their strengths.
The Early Roots of Educational Failure
One of the most important findings in the Milburn Review is that educational disengagement begins much earlier than many policymakers assume.
The report cites research from Bradford showing that children who were not school-ready at ages four to five were almost three times more likely to become NEET during adolescence. Furthermore, the review argues that disengagement frequently begins as early as Year 7.
For SEND learners, this finding is especially significant.
Research consistently demonstrates that language difficulties, literacy challenges, executive functioning deficits and social communication needs often emerge during the early years of development (Snowling & Hulme, 2021).
When these needs remain unidentified or unsupported, pupils may experience repeated academic failure.
Over time, this can contribute to:
- Reduced self-confidence
- Poor attendance
- School avoidance
- Behavioural difficulties
- Mental health concerns
- Lower aspirations
The Milburn Review notes that some pupils describe school as:
“traumatic”, “stressful” and “boring”.
These findings align with SEND research. Humphrey and Hebron (2015) found that autistic pupils frequently report significantly higher levels of anxiety, exclusion and social isolation within educational settings.
If disengagement begins early and remains unaddressed, the likelihood of successful transition into employment inevitably decreases.
GCSEs and the Examination Culture Problem
The review is particularly critical of England’s examination culture.
Former pupils repeatedly described GCSEs as:
“a source of dread rather than anything that felt fair or useful.”
This criticism is especially relevant for SEND learners.
Although access arrangements such as extra time, readers and scribes can help reduce barriers, many SEND pupils continue to face significant challenges within high-stakes assessment systems.
Examinations often require:
- Rapid information processing
- Sustained concentration
- Extended writing
- Strong working memory
- Emotional resilience
For pupils with autism, ADHD, dyslexia, developmental language disorder or learning difficulties, these demands can create barriers unrelated to subject knowledge.
The review further argues that the limited range of assessment approaches available at Key Stage 4 contributes to educational exclusion.
This concern echoes recommendations made by the Francis Curriculum and Assessment Review, which described current assessment arrangements as excessive and recommended reducing examination time by at least 10 per cent.
Assessment reform alone will not solve the challenges facing SEND learners. However, it may help create a system that recognises a broader range of strengths and abilities.
The Missing Link: Preparing SEND Learners for Employment
Perhaps the most significant finding in the Milburn Review concerns the disconnect between education and employment.
The report reveals that:
- Only 47% of young people felt ready for work when leaving education.
- Only 36% of young people who became NEET felt prepared for employment.
- Only 32% reported receiving face-to-face careers guidance.
- Apprenticeships were discussed with just 18% of young people.
These statistics are concerning for all learners.
For SEND pupils, they are alarming.
The transition from education into employment is often significantly more challenging for young people with SEND. Many require explicit teaching of workplace behaviours, communication skills and social expectations.
Research consistently demonstrates that disabled young people experience poorer employment outcomes than their non-disabled peers.
The review also notes that work experience has become:
“an afterthought for many schools.”
Yet for SEND learners, work experience can be transformational.
Supported internships, employer partnerships and structured workplace opportunities allow pupils to develop practical skills, confidence and professional networks.
Department for Education (2023) guidance highlights that supported internships can significantly improve employment outcomes for young people with learning difficulties and autism.
The evidence therefore suggests that preparation for employment should be embedded throughout education rather than treated as an optional add-on during Key Stage 4 or post-16 provision.
Why Current Accountability Systems Continue to Drive Failure
A major theme emerging from the Milburn Review is that accountability structures shape educational priorities.
Schools naturally focus on what they are measured against.
If inspection frameworks, performance tables and public accountability measures prioritise examination outcomes, schools will inevitably devote significant resources towards improving those outcomes.
The review argues that destination data receives far less attention.
Although the Department for Education publishes post-school destination measures, these do not substantially influence Ofsted judgements or school funding decisions. As the report states:
“A metric that carries no consequence is not accountability, but at best information.”
For SEND learners, this creates a perverse incentive.
Schools can be judged highly successful even if significant numbers of vulnerable pupils struggle to access employment, further education or independent living after leaving school.
If education is genuinely intended to prepare young people for adulthood, then accountability systems must place greater value on long-term outcomes.
Recommendations for Schools
While national reform is necessary, schools can take practical steps to address the concerns identified within the review.
1. Make Preparation for Adulthood a Whole-School Priority
Preparation for adulthood should not begin in Year 11.
Schools should explicitly teach:
- Communication skills
- Workplace behaviours
- Financial literacy
- Problem-solving
- Self-advocacy
- Independence
throughout a pupil’s educational journey.
2. Strengthen Early Identification and Intervention
The review’s findings highlight the importance of early intervention.
Schools should invest in:
- Speech and language screening
- Literacy interventions
- Executive functioning support
- Social communication programmes
- Robust SEND assessment processes
3. Transform Careers Education for SEND Learners
Every SEND learner should have access to:
- Personalised careers guidance
- Employer encounters
- Workplace visits
- Work experience
- Apprenticeship information
- Supported internship opportunities
4. Broaden Definitions of Success
Schools should monitor:
- Independence
- Attendance
- Communication development
- Wellbeing
- Employability skills
- Destination outcomes
alongside academic attainment.
5. Develop Strong Employer Partnerships
Schools should actively collaborate with employers to create meaningful workplace opportunities for SEND learners.
6. Advocate for Accountability Reform
Educational leaders should support reforms that place greater emphasis on long-term outcomes, preparation for adulthood and employment participation.
Conclusion: A System Failing by Design Cannot Deliver Inclusion
The Milburn Review offers a powerful critique of England’s education system. Its central argument is that the system has become overly focused on qualifications while paying insufficient attention to employment, independence and adult outcomes.
For SEND learners, this critique is particularly significant.
Many have spent years navigating a system that often values examination performance above communication, resilience, independence and practical competence. Yet these are precisely the skills that frequently determine success in adulthood.
The challenge facing policymakers is therefore not simply one of curriculum reform or examination reform. It is a question of purpose.
If schools continue to be judged primarily by examination outcomes, many SEND learners will remain vulnerable to exclusion from employment and wider society.
If, however, education begins to value preparation for adulthood as highly as academic attainment, then the system may finally start delivering on its promise of inclusion.
Until then, the risk remains that many SEND pupils will continue to experience exactly what Milburn describes: a system that is not failing by accident, but failing by design.
References
- Department for Education (2023) Supported Internships: Guidance for Education Providers. London: DfE.
- Humphrey, N. and Hebron, J. (2015) ‘Bullying of children and adolescents with autism spectrum conditions: A mixed-methods study of risk and protective factors’, Autism, 19(6), pp. 730–741.
- Milburn, A. (2026) Youth Guarantee Advisory Board Interim Review. Referenced in: ‘School system “failing by design” to prepare pupils for work, review finds’.
- Norwich, B. (2014) Changing Policy and Practice for Special Educational Needs and Inclusion. London: Routledge.
- Snowling, M.J. and Hulme, C. (2021) The Science of Reading: A Handbook. Oxford: Blackwell.






Leave a Reply